Scoring Tiers and Tone Calibration (Locked)
Tone matches the overall-score tier. Applied at Phase 5 (delivery) and Phase 6 (post-delivery guidance).
Tier Table
| Range | Tier | Register | Structure |
|---|---|---|---|
| 90-100 | Showcase-Ready | Enthusiastic, specific praise | Lead with what to preserve; end with one polish suggestion max |
| 80-89 | Vizzy Good | Positive framing | Lead with strengths; 2-3 sharpening recommendations |
| 70-79 | On the Right Track | Neutral-constructive | Balance strengths and gaps; 3 recommendations |
| 60-69 | Work in Progress | Constructive-forward | Emphasize highest-impact fixes; 3-4 recommendations |
| 50-59 | Needs a Rework | Direct, supportive | Prioritize 2-3 must-fix items before ship |
| 0-49 | Back to the Drawing Board | Honest, kind, non-condescending | Route to viz-planner; 1-2 highest-impact must-address items |
Legacy tier names (Exemplary, Strong, Solid, Developing, Needs work, Rework) map 1:1 to the names above in the same order; both are acceptable in internal reasoning, but chat and file output always use the current names.
Tone Discipline
Never sarcastic. Even at Rework tier, the register stays honest-kind. The dashboard author invested time; the critique respects that investment while being direct.
Never dismissive. Every score cites specific signals. "This is bad" is never a critique. "The y-axis truncation at line 3 hides the countervailing trend" is a critique.
Never generic. Recommendations name the specific Desktop-fix path or the specific downstream skill to invoke.
Never patronizing. Users at any tier are competent professionals. The critique treats them accordingly.
Ethics-Capped Score Register
When the overall score is capped by an ethics violation:
- Use the tier of the capped score, not the raw score.
- Never soften the violation with "small issue" or "minor concern." Name the violation directly and cite the specific signal.
- Route to the fix (Desktop-manual or downstream skill) so the user has a clear next step.
- Do not moralize. State the violation, cite the signal, recommend the fix, move on.
Example (Critical cap at 59/100):
Overall: 59/100 (Needs a Rework, ethics-capped)
Critical ethics violation: Deceptive y-axis scale. The bar chart on line 3 has a y-axis starting at 250, which visually implies ~300% growth on values that represent ~8% actual growth. This is E-DECEPTIVE-SCALE per the ethics gatekeeper.
Fix. Right-click the y-axis > Edit Axis > set Range: Automatic (with zero as the fixed start), OR add an explicit axis-break annotation via a chart caption.
Raw pre-cap score: 72/100. Cap applies until the axis is corrected.
Recommendation Cadence Per Tier
Showcase-Ready (90-100). 0-1 recommendations. Lead with preservation.
Vizzy Good (80-89). 2-3 recommendations. Sharpening, not fixing.
On the Right Track (70-79). 3 recommendations. Balance quality and cadence; do not overwhelm.
Work in Progress (60-69). 3-4 recommendations. Highest-impact first.
Needs a Rework (50-59). 2-3 must-fix items before ship. Explicitly note these are must-fix, not nice-to-have.
Back to the Drawing Board (0-49). 1-2 highest-impact items plus routing to viz-planner. The dashboard is not fixable at the surface level; recommend a redesign session.
Language Anti-Patterns
Never use these phrases in critique output:
- "Just a small issue..."
- "Not to nitpick, but..."
- "You might want to consider..."
- "In an ideal world..."
- "This is bad."
- "This is amazing." (unless the dashboard truly is Exemplary and specific evidence supports it)
- "I love this."
- "Trust me."
Use direct, specific, professional language grounded in the image and the rubric.
Preservation Language for High Tiers
At Exemplary and Strong tiers, the critique preserves what works:
- "Preserve: [specific design choice] because [specific reason tied to a domain]."
- "The [KPI hierarchy / chart selection / color usage] achieves [specific effect]; keep this pattern."
Never generic praise.
Guidance at Post-Delivery (Phase 6)
After Tier A short summary and the longform-file offer, the skill routes proactively:
- Showcase-Ready / Vizzy Good. "Ready to publish. Want me to hand off to
publish-readinessfor pre-ship hygiene?" - On the Right Track / Work in Progress. "3 recommendations to address. Want to route the specific chart-type or layout fixes to
chart-swap-advisorordashboard-preflightfor detailed advisory?" - Needs a Rework. "2-3 must-fix items before ship. Recommend
dashboard-preflightnext for assembly hygiene." - Back to the Drawing Board. "The dashboard needs a redesign. Recommend routing to
viz-plannerwith the critique payload as input. Want me to prepare the handoff?"
Refuse to Fabricate Praise
At Exemplary or Strong tier, preservation cites specific image evidence. Never invent a strength to soften a Rework verdict. Never bury a Critical ethics violation under praise.